The FIA demands stricter CFTC rules owing to CME Group’s Futures Commission Merchant (FCM) status, which boosts market risks and industry concentration.
The recent sanction granted to CME Group for establishing its Futures Commission Merchant (FCM) has given rise to concerns within the industry. The Financial Industry Association (FIA) has expressed concerns about potential systemic risks. It has encouraged the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) to resolve any conflicts arising from CME’s expanded market role.
FIA’s Apprehensions Regarding Market Consolidation Risks
The FIA brought up the issue of increased hazards associated with market consolidation in CME’s operations. According to FIA President Walt Lukken, the approval indicates a trend in the financial industry where singular organizations oversee multiple functions, such as trading, clearing, and intermediation.
Lukken underscored that “the approval of CME’s FCM application is the most recent and significant example of a concerning market structure.” The FIA contends that the potential conflicts of interest resulting from this multifunctionality in a singular entity are particularly acute in financial markets already susceptible to systemic risk.
Additionally, Lukken noted that the FIA had previously expressed comparable reservations when FTX applied for CFTC approval with a vertically integrated business model three years ago. At that time, the FIA issued a warning regarding the potential conflicts of interest that could arise from the consolidation of multiple market functions under a single structure. This concern remains relevant as CME continues to expand its operations.
CME’s Strategic Adaptation and Expansion
The National Futures Association (NFA) has approved CME Group, predominantly involved in the derivatives market, to establish an FCM. This move will strengthen the company’s position in the global financial landscape.
Terry Duffy, CEO of CME Group, observed that the FCM model enables the company to be more responsive to the requirements of its clients in response to market fluctuations. The company provides products across various asset categories, such as equities, foreign exchange, and commodities, and is involved in over-the-counter transactions, futures, and options.
The FCM approval is consistent with CME’s strategy of providing a comprehensive range of products and services to expand its market base and meet the requirements of both retail and institutional clients.
The group’s most recent financial results are promising, as the third quarter of 2024 established new performance standards regarding trading volumes, supported by increasing institutional activity and interest rate transactions. Duffy provided additional details regarding CME’s intentions to improve service delivery, emphasizing the strategic nature of servicing clients in a wholly integrated FCM model.
FIA Urges for Immediate CFTC Rulemaking
In response, the FIA has suggested that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission establish regulations to address conflicts of interest in vertically integrated financial institutions, including CME. Lukken also emphasized that the CFTC’s present guidelines need to provide a distinct definition of the legal frameworks for these business models.
“The CFTC has not yet suggested clear guidelines that would help prevent conflicts of interest among the CFTC-regulated participants.”
The FIA’s recommendations to the CFTC exceed those of CME, as the association encourages the regulator to enforce policies that apply to all participants who aspire to hold multiple roles. The organization has suggested that additional strict measures be implemented to safeguard the market’s integrity by preventing conflicts of interest during service provision.
Lukken asserted that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission is under pressure to reasonably regulate the market for all market participants due to the recent approval of CME’s FCM.
Additionally, CME has maintained its financial performance and investors’ confidence by persisting in implementing its FCM model. The group reported a significant increase in its business during the third quarter of 2024, attributed to the active engagement of retail and institutional investors and the increasing average daily trading volume.
Consequently, revenue increased by 18% yearly due to a 36% increase in interest-rate trading volumes. Despite the potential challenges presented by its expanded role, the company’s stock has performed well, indicating a positive market outlook.
